Your Budgeting Questions—Answered

By MP Dunleavey Sunday February 28, 2010
This post is about budgeting, saving, spending


dw_savings2 A post last week on the "Save-to-Spend" budget sparked numerous questions from readers.

Here, our best answers:

My monthly income is so low I can barely pay the bills. How can I budget to save?
Don't think of the saving part of your budget as a loss (as in: "I don't have the money"); think of it as a gain. When you're broke, squirreling away even the spare change at the bottom of your purse is a plus. Establishing the habit is more important than the amount, for now. Even a few bucks stashed away builds optimism.

I'm a freelancer and my income is erratic. How can I set up a regular budget like this?
Your bills are monthly, even if your income isn't. Start there. What's your monthly total for basic living expenses? Let's say it's $2,000 for housing, utilities, food, etc. Aim to save a percentage of that (e.g. 5% = $100) in each budget category, or aim to save a percentage of each freelance paycheck.

How do you set up savings for four different categories? Do I need four different accounts?
The value of having separate accounts is that you're less likely to abscond with your own money. If you earmark the funds in each account for that purpose, you won't spend the money until that specific need arises.

I live in an area of the country with higher-than-average housing costs. I don't think this budget makes sense.
The save-to-spend system is based on target amounts. If your basic living expenses are more like 65%, adjust accordingly (or scale back).

Comments (13)add
Written by Mansi Shah, March 01, 2010
Is it better for me to save money and build my savings/emergency fund or should I pay off my student loans that have interest rates between 5-8%?
Written by Amanda Steinberg (DailyWorth founder), March 01, 2010
@Mansi - You need to build least 6 months in emergency funds while making regular student loan payments. After you establish that fund, if you can increase your loan payments, do it. But first, you need a reserve of cash. Make sense?
Written by Miranda Spencer, March 01, 2010
This info is very helpful. I've decided to set that $2K budget and everything else goes into savings (if only leaving me something for a rainy day). And I'm going to save random coins and bills that always lie around the house and at the bottom of my purse. Even if I save only $5 a month, it's saving. Thanks.
Written by Kenia, March 01, 2010
Savings spare change here and there makes a bigger difference than people realize. According to Coinstar, the average household has $90 in spare change just lying around. So check between those sofa cushions, under your car seats, and remember to check pockets before doing the laundry!! Coinstar (Find a kiosk to change those coins into cash): http://www.coinstar.com/us/WebDocs/A1-0-1
Written by dreamcatcher, March 01, 2010
Ok, I have emptied out my pockets, cleaned out my sofa, and purse, and even my desk at work. I have a little money put in a piggy bank at home. I also got money in my sons account, which I have made the rule of not touching unless I have a real emergancy. And I plan on starting my resolution of emergancy fund money. I am back on track again.
I am gonna start with the answer to question 1. and the answer to 3. I have a low income. and I want to start different savings accounts, for different places in my life. So wish me luck.
Written by Sue Crawford, March 01, 2010
All right, you've convinced me to count my loose change instead of just throwing it in a container. I really enjoy your articles. I like thinking of a savings as a positive instead of a negative.
Written by Linna, March 01, 2010
Great advice about being sure to sock away money for yourself and for your future! I budget savings as an "expense" to pay myself! Also, opening up several savings accounts for different savings goal is very easy, especially with online savings accounts (such as ING Direct or HSBC Advance).

Lastly, do not use Coinstar! They charge you money for counting your change. Just go to TDBank and use their free coin counter.
Written by Amanda Steinberg (DailyWorth founder), March 01, 2010
On the subject of loose change and piggy banks, we've encourage our 3yo son to take any loose change he finds around the house and put it in his piggy bank as his toy fund. The kid has already amassed like $12!! I think we need to revisit this offer! I can't believe how much I've ignored change in my house. I bet we have one week's of groceries in quarters laying around. Fascinating, really.
Written by Johnica Dingus, March 01, 2010
Unfortunately due to bad habits from the past and a bout with someone stealing from me, I am now on the bad check list. As a result I an no longer able to have bank accounts. I do have a re-loadable Visa card with direct deposit. Is there any way I can have an account that is just for saving that earns interest like an orange account? I hear they have a great interest rate and they are directly linked to your bank account which the visa card provides?
Written by Sarah, March 01, 2010
I'm a freelancer and used to find it hard to budget, as my income is so erratic. But I've worked out a system that works: I've set up a budget and I pay myself a "wage" each fortnight on the same date that my husband gets paid. I know that I need to earn a certain amount each fortnight to cover our bills - including a small amount for savings, I treat "savings" as a "bill"! - so that's my earnings goal. It seems to work!
Written by Trainerpack, March 01, 2010
My work is hard to budget with since I am self employed and my income varies each month. Thanks for the tip.
Written by Kenia, March 01, 2010
@ Linna: Thanks for pointing out that Coinstar charges! In my excitement at discovering the fact about households having $90 in spare change lying around, I didn't completely read the very page I linked to in my above comment. Looks like they charge 9.8% of the amount you put in!! I will definitely go to TDBank. Thanks for the heads up! :)
Written by mp dunleavey, March 03, 2010
The other thing to remember is that however you save, whatever method or trick you choose, make it regular. do it every day. you brush your teeth every day, right? if you brushed only as often as you saved, that would be gross, right? so aim to bring your savings in line with brushing your teeth. if not daily, then predictable, non-negotiable. at bed time, take a few coins or bucks out of your wallet. or do a savings sweep every sunday night.
Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy

Show Other Articles Of This Author