Debt Diet Part III, Time to File Bankruptcy?

By Gerri Detweiler and Mary Reed Tuesday March 09, 2010
This post is about credit, debt

debt-diet_280x370 This post is a follow-up to Debt Diets Part I and Part II."

Mary Reed and Gerri Detweiler are co-authors of "Debt Collection Answers: How to Use Debt Collection Laws to Protect Your Rights." They also answer debt questions at DebtCollectionAnswers.com


Bankruptcy is a painful choice and a complicated one. But if you’ve trimmed your spending to the bare bones and you’re still weighed down by too much debt, it may be time for the most drastic of our three debt diets.

The beauty of bankruptcy is that once you've filed, all attempts to collect your debts stop. That's why it's sometimes called "bankruptcy protection."

There are two types of bankruptcy: Chapter 7, liquidation, and Chapter 13, reorganization. A bankruptcy attorney can tell you which one may work for you. 

Chapter 7, Liquidation: This option is typically best if you have a lot of unsecured debt (e.g. credit card and medical bills), and few assets.

Credit card and medical debt other kinds of unsecured debt are wiped out (discharged). But in return, the court may sell some of your assets—like your car—and give the money to creditors.

Remember that some types of debt—like student loans, unpaid income taxes, and child and spousal support—cannot be erased.

In Chapter 7, you get a choice about how to handle any secured debt you may owe, like your car loan and mortgage. You can:
  1. Formally agree to continue paying the debt.
  2. Buy the asset that secures the debt—i.e. pay off your car—assuming you and the lender can agree on its current value, and that you can pay for it with one lump sum.
  3. Return or surrender the asset to your lender so it can be sold and the cash applied toward what you owe.
Chapter 13, Reorganization: This option could be best if you have assets to protect (like your home), and have some money to pay off part or most of what you owe.

You keep your assets in exchange for paying all or some of your debts, depending on the type, under a plan the court must approve. Once you’ve completed the plan—usually in 3 to 5 years—any remaining dischargeable debt is wiped out and your bankruptcy is over.

Filing for bankruptcy can be a huge relief if you’ve got a ton of debt, but it will leave scars: Your bankruptcy will be in the public record for years to come, and your credit history will take a big hit for up to ten years.

However, you can begin rebuilding your credit once your bankruptcy is filed, and you embrace better money habits.

If you need help deciding whether this is the right step for you, read When is Bankruptcy the Right Choice?

Resources
Find a federally-approved credit counseling agency. You must complete a consultation with one no less than 180 days before you file bankruptcy. To find an agency, go to http://www.uscourts.gov/bankruptcycourts/approvedagencies.html.

Find a board certified bankruptcy attorney. Locate one in your area at http://www.abcworld.org/search or at http://www.nacba.org.
Comments (7)add
Written by Anne Watson, March 09, 2010
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy does payoff all your back taxes.
Written by Jaime, March 09, 2010
One of my favorite online financial writers, Liz Pulliam Weston, said (and I paraphrase so blame me if I get it wrong, not her) that part of your considerations for filing should include how long it takes to repair your credit vs. how long it would take you to pay off your debt. So, if your credit will be trashed for 7 years (bankruptcy is not as big a deal as it once was, but as an example I'll use the classic 7 years) but it'll take you 10 years to pay off your debt yourself - might be a good idea to file bankruptcy. If you can pay off your debt in 3 years though, it might be a better option to pay it off.

That is a very general consideration and she wrote more, but I love one aspect of the point I think she was making. Mainly, sometimes I think people feel so overwhelmed by the thought that it might take years to pay off that they think bankruptcy is the only option. However, paying off your debt IS part of your responsibility and while 3 or 4 or 5 years is a long time, well that's life. I know that many people declare bankruptcy when they really need to - they have outrageous hospital bills or a failed business. However, I've personally known several people who declared bankruptcy because they spent irresponsibly and lived beyond their means - they didn't take responsibility for their spending when they were buying things and certainly didn't take responsibility for the resultant debts.

On the other hand, there is the emotional stress of so much debt as well. I want people to be proactive and take control of their debt, take responsibility but I don't think that someone should be tortured for making mistakes. I just hate to see people giving up too early - it IS tough to pay it off and it should be. If it was easy to pay off your debt then you wouldn't be as likely to learn your lesson for next time. I know it took 2 painful years of paying off completely unnecessary credit card debt to really beat the lesson into my skull.
Written by MP Dunleavey, March 09, 2010
Liz is a colleague of mine at MSN Money--and I read that piece of hers, too. Thank you for mentioning it!
Written by MP Dunleavey, March 09, 2010
I forgot to address Anne's comment: You can file for tax bankruptcy, but ch. 7 alone doesn't include taxes.
Written by krist, March 09, 2010
Actually, you can discharge student loans in bankruptcy when there is a finding of undue hardship.
Written by CREDITOR, March 10, 2010
So unfair..... All the laws and protection are for the debtor, what about an article to help the creditor?

Written by Gerri, March 12, 2010
Krist - It's been very difficult for most student loan borrowers to meet the standards that allow for discharge of student loan debts in bankruptcy. Once in a while it happens, but it's far from common.

Jaime - That was a good article, as was MP's article in the New York Times on this topic.


Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy

Show Other Articles Of This Author